Joint Statement by Christian leaders on the passing of asylum seeker legislation

Sunday, 02 September 2012

As Australian church leaders, we stand together to express our grave concern at the passing of legislation to allow for the offshore processing and indefinite detention of asylum seekers.

Core to the Christian faith is the principle of ‘welcoming the stranger’, and Jesus’ parable of the Good Samaritan guides us as we seek to care for those who are vulnerable and marginalised in society. As Christians, we are called to cross the road to help, to not turn away those in need.

The Seventh Forum of the National Council of Churches in Australia in 2010 called on all political parties to meet Australia’s responsibilities by “accommodating and processing in Australia asylum seekers who reach Australian territory”.

Australia is an open and hospitable country. Many of our churches grew here as a result of people having fled places of violence or migrating to seek better futures for their families.

We welcome the commitment of the Government to increase the number of places in our humanitarian program to 20,000 and hope that it will continue to increase the program as the Houston Panel has recommended.

However, we are deeply troubled by the potential for asylum seekers to suffer adverse mental health consequences and to experience other detrimental impacts as a result of this legislation. We are concerned that this damages our credibility and, in particular, our ability to negotiate a humane regional system of protection.

Finding answers to this complicated humanitarian challenge is difficult. As long as our world is broken and countries are ravaged by war, then people will flee violence and persecution.

But as a rich and secure nation, Australia has a particular responsibility to ensure that we work positively with other nations to develop a range of strategies that are grounded in compassion and that seek to honour the moral responsibility we have to victims of violence and persecution.

It is only through such cooperation that we can provide asylum seekers with real alternatives to undertaking a desperate boat journey to find safety.


The Most Reverend Doctor Phillip Aspinall
Primate, Anglican Church in Australia

Reverend Craig Brown
Federal Coordinator, Churches of Christ in Australia

Commissioner James Condon
Australia Eastern Territory, The Salvation Army

Ms Maxine Cooper
Yearly Meeting Clerk, Religious Society of Friends

Reverend Professor Andrew Dutney
President, Uniting Church in Australia

Dr Joe Goodall
Moderator, Congregational Federation of Australia and Aotearoa-New Zealand

The Most Reverend Denis Hart
President, Australian Catholic Bishops Conference

2 September 2012

3 thoughts on “Joint Statement by Christian leaders on the passing of asylum seeker legislation

  1. akismet-333148c5c2e674225136a85ccb9527ef September 3, 2012 — 2:03 pm

    Thanks for this Dennis.

    It’s a heartening response to a situation made difficult, not so much by the enormity of the task, but by the ingrained cultural resistance in the Australian population, including its legislative leaders.

    Perhaps the TV’s ‘Go back to where you came from’ series will begin to soften the hardness of heart, while recognising the political and economic realities of the situation.

    Have you seen any attempt to compare the cost of our migration and detention policies with the alternative cost of widespread housing and accommodation facilities?

    In prayer,


  2. Denis
    I haven’t come across any data comparing the cost effectiveness of onshore processing vs off-shore but I’m sure it exists! I’ll see what I can find out.

  3. Denis

    It appears the comparative data either does not exist or is well-hidden (probably for suitable political reasons). There is some guesstimation available through articles such as

What do you think? Please leave your comment here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close